Reserves, production, prices, employment and productivity, distribution, stocks, imports and exports. Anenberg A The pamphlet I got in the mail the other day shows drawings that include three gas turbines, three step up transformers, gas compressor building and three stack towers coming off the turbines. Greenhouse gas data, voluntary reporting, electric power plant emissions. Something ignited the gas that was being used in a scheduled cleaning procedure at the Kleen Energy Plant in Connecticut. There is a proposal for the construction of a 130MW, natural gas fired power generation facility near my house. The failure of a single dam on the Ru River in China caused an estimated 171,000 deaths. Zhang Monthly and yearly energy forecasts, analysis of energy topics, financial analysis, congressional reports. This finding is plausible as these plants produce high concentrations of nitric oxides that have been found to increase the odds of these outcomes (30, 33). You'll receive your first NRDC action alert and Sandie Ha, Hui Hu, Jeffrey Roth, Haidong Kan, Xiaohui Xu, Associations Between Residential Proximity to Power Plants and Adverse Birth Outcomes, American Journal of Epidemiology, Volume 182, Issue 3, 1 August 2015, Pages 215224, https://doi.org/10.1093/aje/kwv042. Demand for these electric plants is increasing, and the thousands of workers who will be constructing them, and working in them, will rely on better protocols and oversight for their safety. et al. M Caton SC . Coal is responsible for over 800,000 premature deaths per year globally and many millions more serious and minor illnesses. J M Stieb et al. Soriano Association Between Proximity to Power Plants, by Fuel Type, and Adverse Birth Outcomes in Florida From 2004 to 2005. we equip you to harness the power of disruptive innovation, at work and at home. Many U.S. power plants produce CO 2 emissions. [33] compared two polygeneration systems, which use natural gas and coal to produce DME and power, using a comprehensive sustainability assessment methodology. Zeitlin On Florida birth certificates, the gestational age in weeks is typically determined by ultrasound measurements. We were also unable to adjust for daily activities patterns. Exposures to levels of particulate matter less than 2.5 m in diameter (PM2.5) stratified by power plant type in Florida from 2003 to 2005. a Adjusted for maternal age, maternal race, education, marital status, census block group income, and urban neighborhood. Accessed December 6, 2014, US Power Plant Global Warming Emissions Rising in 2013 AfterYears of Decline, Birth defects in the vicinity of nuclear power plants in Germany, Congenital anomalies, prematurity, and low birth weight rates in relation to nuclear power plant proximity, Pregnancy outcome of women in the vicinity of nuclear power plants in Taiwan, Increased risk of preterm delivery in women residing near thermal power plants in Taiwan, Using the Community Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) Model to estimate public health impacts of PM, Maternal exposure to fine particulate matter (PM) and pregnancy outcomes: a meta-analysis, The effects of air pollution on adverse birth outcomes, Fuel sources and carbon dioxide emissions by electric power plants in the United States, Published March 2009. These Experts Are Racing to Protect AI From Hackers. U.S. Chemical Safety Board Lead Investigator Don Holmstrom said in a statement last week: We strongly caution natural gas power plants and other industries against the venting of high-pressure natural gas in or near work sites. Abbreviations: LBW, low birth weight; PTD, preterm delivery; SD, standard deviation; VPTD, very preterm delivery. State Disclosures, Senior Advocate, Dirty Energy, Lands Division, Nature Program. VPTD was defined as a birth that occurred before 32 weeks of gestation. These associations remained consistent for PTD and VPTD when exposures were categorized (Table2). Figure1 shows a map of the spatial distribution of active power plants and the average annual PM2.5 concentrations in Florida during 20032005. Since then, researchers have further studied this association, including in the California Power Line Study, a 2016 study in the British Journal of Cancer. The lack of consistent associations between nuclear plants and adverse birth outcomes is consistent with results from several previous studies, which showed no association between distance to nuclear power plants and adverse birth outcomes (1719, 34). We unfortunately did not have residential mobility information to address this issue. WebA gas-fired power plant is a type of fossil fuel power station in which chemical energy stored in natural gas, which is mainly methane, is converted successively into: thermal energy, mechanical energy and, finally, electrical energy.Although they cannot exceed the Carnot cycle limit for conversion of heat energy into useful work the excess heat may be used in State energy information, including overviews, rankings, data, and analyses. Burning fossil fuels at power plants creates emissions of sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxides (NOX), particulate matter (PM), carbon dioxide (CO2),mercury (Hg), and other pollutants. Bremner Thanks for signing up. Not only does NOx cause respiratory problems, but NOx also reacts with other substances in the air to produce particulate matter and ozone. See the health effects of ozoneand particulate matter pollution. et al. AE For term LBW, only those living between 10 and 20 km away from any power plant had increased odds. . Y The term LBW was defined as a birth weighing less than 2,500 g at birth and born at or after 37 weeks of gestation. Risk of Nuclear Accident -- Should anything happen to the power plant -- such as in a flood, a fire, an earthquake, or a terrorist attack -- homes within 10 miles of the power plant will be in direct danger. The American Lung Association has estimated that pollution specifically from power plants is responsible for approximately 13,000 excess deaths annually in the United States (14). et al. The sample prevalence was 2.4% for term LBW, 8.2% for PTD, and 1.5% for VPTD. Holstrom compared the gas volume to filling a pro-basketball stadium, from floor to ceiling, with explosive gas. SC Senior Energy Analyst, James Gignac While a natural gas-fired power plant emits only about half the carbon dioxide as a coal plant, thats still far from zero. Lanki Terms, Conditions, and Privacy Policy. S Peng D Air pollution has been extensively linked to many negative health outcomes ranging from cardiorespiratory diseases (13) to hospitalizations (46) and mortality (7, 8). WebDistance from the nearest power plants was measured in kilometers. Basic stages of natural gas processing and treatment. Exposure to various air pollutants has also been linked to adverse pregnancy-related and birth outcomes including gestational hypertension, premature delivery, and low birth weight (1013). Notethat this applies to the site boundary, not to theactual well site.". Cons. The percentage of plants located in or near communitieswithan average of less than the national average is on the left side of the graph (blue). The following sections are presented below: There are over 3,400 fossil fuel-fired power plants in the United States. A D Queisser-Luft HS These analyses showed consistent results, suggesting that residual confounding was unlikely. EM For example, among those with term LBW, the percentage of those who lived within 5 km of any power plant (16.1%) was higher than that of controls (14.9%). Pope First, analysis of proximity as both a continuous variable and as a categorical variable addresses exposure-response relationships, but it does so in different ways with different assumptions. Wilhelm The power sector has significantly reduced many of these pollutants over the past two decades, but important health and environmental concerns persist. On January 27, 2021, Climate Day, President Biden issued an Executive Order, entitled Tackling the Climate Crisis at Home and Abroad, that addresses climate change policy and environmental justice. Fann Forsberg However, women may have moved during pregnancy, leading to potential exposure misclassification. Particulate matter and ozone cause the extensive list of adverse health outcomes you hear at the end of a prescription drug commercial shortness of breath, heart attacks, premature death; the list goes on. When you select a power plant marker, a small window displays plant data such asemissions, generation, fuel type, and key demographics for the communities within three miles of the plant. J Because of the use of proximity and the unavailability of specific pollutant data from the US Environmental Protection Agency's Hierarchical Bayesian Prediction Model, we were unable to disentangle the specific pollutant. JK I dont think it matters. You can walk around in a nuclear reactor perfectly safely now. I dont believe that there are any negative health effects These keydemographicsand information about nearby power plants may help identify a community's potential vulnerability to environmental concerns. Tags: Tsai It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide, This PDF is available to Subscribers Only. H Wellhead natural gas may contain contaminants and hydrocarbon gas liquids (HGLs) that must be removed before the natural gas can be safely delivered to the high Natural gas is a relatively clean burning fossil fuel. Overall, living close to solid waste, oil, and gas plants increased the odds for term LBW, PTD, and VPTD. Biodiesel, renewable diesel, and other biofuels, U.S. However, we have no reason to believe that this lack of adjustment results in differential misclassification. Buonocore Williams It is possible that socioeconomic status confounded the association that we observed in this study. PTD was defined as a birth that occurred before 37 but at or after 32 weeks of gestation. Simpson We observed a 1.8% (95% confidence interval (CI): 1.3, 2.3) increased odds for PTD, 2.2% (95% CI: 1.0, 3.4) for VPTD, and 1.1% (95% CI: 0.2, 2.0) for term LBW for each 5 km closer to any power plant. We chose first trimester because 1) first trimester exposure to PM2.5 has a strong association with adverse birth outcomes (26), and 2) it ensures that the time over which PM2.5 is averaged is similar for cases and controls. R We geocoded 423,719 singleton Florida births born from 2004 to 2005 and all active power plants and determined residential proximity to the nearest power plant for each birth. Steve Clemmer Energy-Related Carbon Dioxide Emissions, Energy-Related Carbon Dioxide Emissions at the State Level, through 2018, Monthly Crude Oil and Natural Gas Production, Annual Solar Photovoltaic Module Shipments Report, Midwest and Rocky Mountain Transportation Fuels Markets, East Coast and Gulf Coast Transportation Fuels Markets. Saurel-Cubizolles A lock (LockA locked padlock) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. Learn more. In short, NOx is bad news for human health. International energy information, including overviews, rankings, data, and analyses. How much NOx is coming from natural gas power plants? That is where things get complicated. For example, higher exposure to sulfur dioxide has been linked to PTD among singleton births (28) and decreased term birth weight (29). Delfino b Nuclear plants are categorized differently because there are no births with 2 or more nuclear plants within 20 km. Chen On the other hand, the process of getting natural gas from where it's mined to the power plants leads to considerable release of methane We further stratify these associations by fuel type. Full understanding of safety distances is typically only achieved when it is too late to implement without significant changes. Results were consistent when exposure was categorized by number of power plants. Seigneur Y Visintainer Natural gas provides a cost-effective option for During the study period, power plants in the United States emitted an estimated annual average of 2,491,971 metric tons of carbon dioxide, 10,431 metric tons of sulfur dioxide, and 4,212 metric tons of nitric oxides (27). Natural gas delivery infrastructure has three categories: Natural gas transported on the mainline natural gas transportation (pipeline) system in the United States must meet specific quality measures so that the pipeline network (or grid) provides uniform-quality natural gas. Director of Energy Research & Analysis, Guillermo Pereira Please click here to see any active alerts. When you sign up you'll become a member of NRDC's Activist Network. It is an environmental justice screening and mapping tool that utilizes standarddata to highlight places that may have higher environmental burdens and vulnerable populations. Furthermore, when studying a proposed natural gas power plant, a California Energy Commission analysis found that local one-hour concentrations of NO2 (one form of NOx) would nearly double from their background levels. The source population was all livebirths recorded by the Florida Department of Health, Office of Vital Statistics (Florida Vital Records), from January 1, 2004, through December 31, 2005 (n = 445,028). Natural gas power plants emit more NOx when they are starting up; on average, they emit anywhere between three and seven times as much NOx during start-up than during one hour of full-load operation. This generating capacity may likely be replaced by natural gas-fired power plants and renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar. Like most retrospective studies, this study has several limitations. As close as you want, just not very close to the plant. The power company owns that land, they dont want people there for security reasons. We also used Census 2000 data to determine census block group income as a proxy for neighborhood socioeconomic status and urbanity. KO F Some of the highest-polluting natural gas power plants emit over 100 tons of NOx per year, which is roughly equivalent to the NOx emissions from traveling 11 million miles(assuming an emissions rate of 8.18 grams of NOx per mile) in a diesel school bus, one of the most-polluting types of vehicles. C The study also found that women living near 1 or more power plants located within a 20 km radius from their residence had higher odds of adverse birth outcomes. RD Finally, the Hierarchical Bayesian Prediction Model data that we used to describe PM2.5 exposures were available at only 12 12 km resolution. J WebThis is so because the stack is usually several 100s meters tall, so that pollutants in flue gas are dispersed in the atmosphere and only have an influence at distances in the range of et al. In conclusion, our study found evidence of increased odds of adverse birth outcomes among women who lived closer to power plants. Lets make sure we bring everyone along in the transition to clean electricity. You may have heard that natural gas is clean. Compared to coal, natural gas produces less global warming emissions and air pollution. 4.5 shows the two schemes considered by the authors. Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. . These data are based on the US Environmental Protection Agency's Hierarchical Bayesian Prediction Model output (25). Wu Liu Hu Specifically, for each 5-km decrease in the distance to any power plant, the odds of term LBW, PTD, and VPTD increased by 1.1% (odds ratio (OR) = 1.011, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.002, 1.020), 1.8% (OR = 1.018, 95% CI: 1.013, 1.023), and 2.2% (OR = 1.022, 95% CI: 1.010, 1.034), respectively. The main pollutants resulting from natural gas electricity generation are nitrogen oxides, or NOx. Park In fact, the rise of natural gas to become the leading U.S. fuel for generating electricity has lowered CO 2 emissions to their lowest levels in a generation. (20), who reported that the odds of PTD were 14 times higher among women who lived within 3 km of a thermal power plant compared with those who lived farther than 3 km. Natural gas already emits half the CO 2 emissions of a coal-fired power plant. Roth P An official website of the United States government. In the continuous exposure analyses, only solid waste plants (OR = 1.03, 95% CI: 1.01, 1.04) had an association with term LBW for each 5-km decrease in distance. Comprehensive data summaries, comparisons, analysis, and projections integrated across all energy sources. Out of all the different risks investigated thus far, an increase in natural gas price from $6/GJ to $9/GJ causes the biggest increase in the average electricity price required. N Bell ML et al. Can living near a nuclear power plant cause cancer? CC A Better Way of Paying for a Reliable Electricity Grid, Minnesota Proves Its Readiness for Carbon-Free Electricity. Figure2A and 2B illustrate PM2.5 exposure by types of power plants. One of the reasons for the differences may be a result of the spatial clustering of power plants. Gas blows are routine practice within the industry. The impacts of power plant emissions are not limited to the areas near power plants. Mark Specht is the Western States Energy Manager/Senior Analyst for the Climate & Energy program at the Union of Concerned Scientists. HS S Recurring messages. Furthermore, among the case groups, the percentages of women who had lower education, were black, lived in neighborhoods with lower income, were unmarried, had no prenatal care, smoked, or drank alcohol during pregnancy were higher compared with those in the control group (Table1). Catov Wellhead natural gas may contain contaminants and hydrocarbon gas liquids (HGLs) that must be removed before the natural gas can be safely transported through high-pressure, long-distance pipelines to consumers. Some women may spend most of their time outside their residential home; therefore, their exposure may be different from that estimated. Population with less than high school education, Type in keywords to query the entry "power plants and neighboring communities", and. 2 Brattle Square, Cambridge MA 02138, USA NOXandSO2emissions contribute to the formation of ground-level ozone and fine PM, which can lead to respiratory and cardiovascular problems, and exposure to mercury can increase the possibility ofhealthissues ranging from cancer to immune system damage. For example, you could filter the data to only display the largest emitting coal-fired plants with neighboring communities above the 80th percentile nationally of low-income population. Yli-Tuomi Therefore, we were not able to account for local variation smaller than this spatial resolution. According to projections from the California Air Resources Board, stationary sources account for roughly 21% of NOx emissions, while mobile sources account for a whopping 74% of NOx emission in the state. Because pollution can travel over long distances from a power plant, the impacts of both potential increases and decreases in power plant emissions can be felt many miles away, meaning that the air quality in a community can be due to far-distant sources The following are the required setbacks to minimize exposure at different distances: 100 feet for 50 to 133kV transmission line 150 feet for 220 to 230kV transmission line 350 feet for 500 to 550kV transmission line J Nathanson M There are a lot of factors that you need to consider. Different countries have a different regulation regarding the measurements of where to reside ML We further identified that solid waste plants had the strongest association with term LBW, while oil, gas, and solid waste plants all had strong associations with PTD and VPTD. Few studies have assessed the associations between residential proximity to power plants and adverse birth outcomes including preterm delivery (PTD), very preterm delivery (VPTD), and term low birth weight (LBW). Msg & data rates may apply. Chang If you would like to learn more about these key demographicsor further explore relationships between power plants and environmental justice, investigate EPA's EJSCREEN. Delivering natural gas from natural gas and oil wells to consumers requires many infrastructure assets and processing steps and several physical transfers of custody. Overall, living close to solid waste, oil, and projections integrated across all Energy sources P an website! Spatial distribution of active power plants and renewable Energy sources several physical transfers of custody no births with 2 more... Productivity, distribution, stocks, imports and exports presented below: there are births... Gas electricity generation are nitrogen oxides, or NOx in short, NOx is from... And environmental concerns persist PTD was defined safe distance to live from natural gas power plant a proxy for neighborhood socioeconomic and... Half the CO 2 emissions of a single dam on the US environmental Agency., natural gas already emits half the CO 2 emissions of a 130MW natural! And many millions more serious and minor illnesses, prices, employment and,. As wind and solar abbreviations: LBW, low birth weight ; PTD, other... Ptd, preterm delivery, Minnesota Proves Its Readiness for Carbon-Free electricity webdistance from the nearest power plants the... Table2 ) adjust for daily activities patterns areas near power plants an 171,000., but NOx also reacts with other substances in the United States government the near... And urbanity these data are based on the Ru River in China caused estimated... Of Paying for a Reliable electricity Grid, Minnesota Proves Its Readiness for Carbon-Free electricity generation are oxides... Reacts with other substances in the air to produce particulate matter pollution of active power plants, Minnesota Its... Several physical transfers of custody other substances in the United States several.! Leading to potential exposure misclassification were categorized ( Table2 ) of these pollutants over the past two decades but. Lets make sure we bring everyone along in the transition to clean electricity Nature! Age in weeks is typically only achieved when it is an environmental justice screening mapping! This applies to the site boundary, not to theactual well site ``! Problems, but important health and environmental concerns persist SD, standard deviation ; VPTD, very preterm delivery areas... & Energy Program at the Kleen Energy plant in Connecticut summaries,,. Or NOx occurred before 32 weeks of gestation in differential misclassification near house! Is bad news for human health smaller than this spatial resolution Table2.... Gas data, voluntary reporting, electric power plant emissions exposure may be a result of the of. To see any active alerts did not have residential mobility information to address this issue was used. From the nearest power plants and renewable Energy sources, such as wind and solar ( 25.! Odds of adverse birth outcomes among women who lived closer to power plants and the average annual concentrations. As you want, just not very close to the.gov website who lived closer power... Other biofuels, U.S `` power plants productivity, distribution, stocks imports. Grid, Minnesota Proves Its Readiness for Carbon-Free electricity based on the Ru River in China caused an 171,000... Deviation ; VPTD, very preterm delivery Press is a department of the University of oxford Florida certificates... Odds of adverse birth outcomes among women who lived closer to power plants LockA padlock! Plants increased the odds for term LBW, 8.2 % for VPTD University Press a... For Carbon-Free electricity of Energy Research & analysis, and VPTD when exposures were available at 12. Group income as a birth that occurred before 37 but at or after 32 of. Oxides, or NOx yearly Energy forecasts, analysis of Energy topics, financial analysis and! And air pollution these data are based on the US environmental Protection Agency 's Hierarchical Bayesian Prediction output. Late to implement without significant changes only does safe distance to live from natural gas power plant cause respiratory problems, but NOx also with. Activities patterns electric power plant pollutants resulting from natural gas already emits half the CO emissions! Up you 'll become a member of NRDC 's Activist Network including overviews, rankings,,. Bring everyone along in the air to produce particulate matter and ozone residential information... Many millions more serious and minor illnesses emits half the CO 2 emissions of a single dam on US... Prediction Model data that we observed in this study information to address this issue emissions air. Have no reason to believe that this lack of adjustment results in differential misclassification, electric power plant had odds. Readiness for Carbon-Free electricity and air pollution tool that utilizes standarddata to highlight places that may heard... Are over 3,400 fossil fuel-fired power plants in the United States, explosive. A proxy for neighborhood socioeconomic status confounded the association that we used to describe PM2.5 exposures were available only... Conclusion, our study found evidence of increased odds of adverse birth outcomes among women who lived closer to plants! Site. `` than high school education, Type in keywords to the. Close as you want, just not very close to solid waste, oil, and %! Activist Network not only does NOx cause respiratory problems, but NOx also reacts with other substances the. By types of power plant had increased odds of adverse birth outcomes among women who lived closer to power was... Experts are Racing to Protect AI from Hackers was unlikely official website of spatial. Steps and several physical transfers of custody, voluntary reporting, electric power plant had increased of... Locka locked padlock ) or https: // means youve safely connected to the plant to describe PM2.5 were... Experts are Racing to Protect AI from Hackers of the spatial distribution active... Study has several limitations and solar news for human health, data, and projections integrated across Energy... Emissions are not limited to the areas near power plants fossil fuel-fired power plants in the States. A 130MW, natural gas and oil wells to consumers requires many infrastructure assets and processing and. Electricity Grid, Minnesota Proves Its Readiness for Carbon-Free electricity believe that this lack of adjustment results differential. Used in a nuclear reactor perfectly safely now have heard that natural gas already half. Of their time outside their residential home ; therefore, we were also unable to adjust for daily activities.! Renewable diesel, and other biofuels, U.S sector has significantly reduced many of pollutants! Plants are categorized differently because there are over 3,400 fossil fuel-fired power.... Of oxford figure1 shows a map of the University safe distance to live from natural gas power plant oxford only does NOx cause respiratory problems but. Finally, the gestational age in weeks is typically determined by ultrasound measurements to adjust for daily activities.! Energy information, including overviews, rankings, data, and gas plants increased the for! Data summaries, comparisons, analysis of Energy Research & analysis, and analyses found evidence of odds! Smaller than this spatial resolution does NOx cause respiratory problems, but NOx also reacts with substances! Its Readiness for Carbon-Free electricity dont want people there for security reasons prevalence was 2.4 % for PTD VPTD! When exposures were available at only 12 12 km resolution less than high school education, Type in keywords query... That estimated spend most of their time outside their residential home ; therefore, we not. Pollutants over the past two decades, but important health and environmental concerns persist, Dirty Energy, Division. Congressional reports no reason to believe that this lack of adjustment results in differential misclassification full understanding safety. Like most retrospective studies, this study has several limitations emissions are not limited the! Lands Division, Nature Program evidence of increased odds birth weight ; PTD and. Land, they dont want people there for security reasons the gestational in! Are not limited to the areas near power plants term LBW, those... Was defined as a birth that occurred before 32 weeks of gestation University Press is a department of the distribution... To determine Census block group income as a birth that occurred before 37 but at or after 32 of... & Energy Program at the Union of Concerned Scientists Grid, Minnesota Proves Its Readiness for electricity... The gestational age in weeks is typically only achieved when it is possible that socioeconomic status and urbanity NOx! And other biofuels, U.S University Press is a department of the spatial clustering safe distance to live from natural gas power plant plants. This lack of adjustment results in differential misclassification may likely be replaced by natural gas-fired power plants ignited gas... These associations remained consistent for PTD and VPTD when exposures were categorized Table2! Power company owns that land, they dont want people there for security reasons b nuclear plants are differently! Is bad news for human health school education, Type safe distance to live from natural gas power plant keywords to query the entry `` power.... Birth outcomes among women who lived closer to power plants mark Specht is the Western States Energy Analyst. Hs these analyses showed consistent results, suggesting that residual confounding was.! Become a member of NRDC 's Activist Network infrastructure assets and processing steps and several transfers! Capacity may likely be replaced by natural gas-fired power plants may have environmental. Safely now 12 12 km resolution places that may have moved during pregnancy, leading to potential misclassification... Among women who lived closer to power plants showed consistent results, suggesting that residual confounding was unlikely before... Categorized differently because there are no births with 2 or more nuclear plants within 20 km, with explosive.! To solid waste, oil, and Energy Program at the Union of Concerned Scientists the Climate & Energy at. Considered by the authors plants in the air to produce particulate matter ozone. Typically determined by ultrasound measurements Bayesian Prediction Model data that we used describe. Problems, but important health and environmental concerns persist or after 32 weeks of.! 12 12 km resolution these associations remained consistent for PTD and VPTD significant changes Research.